Pages

Showing posts with label training session. Show all posts
Showing posts with label training session. Show all posts

Tuesday, 3 July 2012

tese & livro


3 july 2012 

 Como falei no primeiro post, eventualmente teremos um texto em inglês.
Esse post traz minhas anotações de uma das muitas ‘training sessions’ oferecidas pela universidade. A gente participa da sessão, escreve anotações e as envia para o departamento para obtenção de créditos. Essa foi uma sessão com dicas de como transformar a tese de doutorado em livro e encontrar uma editora interessada no seu livro. Apesar de refletirem diretamente o contexto europeu, acredito que a maioria das dicas se encaixem em muitos outros contextos, como no brasileiro.

PGR training session: 'How to turn your thesis into a book'
Led by Dr Neil Gregor
Monday 14 May 2012, from 10am -12pm in room 65/1145

The session explored how to turn our PhD thesis into a book.
The bullet points below give account of the tips and suggestions provided by Dr Gregor in the session:
-         Don’t fantasise about being a senior in your field.
-         How many copies would a publisher like to print? About 600. ‘print on demand’ is now very common.
-         How many copies do you think they expect to sell? About 350.
-         We deal with a small readership, i.e. other academics. 90% of people who read our books are undergrads.
-         Make intelligent judgments when revising, cutting. Make sure you provide some key background.
-         First thing to do with a PhD thesis is to close it in a drawer and forget about it for a year.
-         Look at the thesis and ask yourself: ‘where is the book in this?’ Maybe when revising chapters will change in number from thesis to book. If chapter has been pointed out as weak, it can be either revised or cut out.
-         Think of a broad title so that it is more attractive to more people. No random titles and no ‘case study’ on cover or title.
-         Sign post to help the readers. Use good and pre-empt with chapter headings to help the reader follow you. Sign post the argument.
-         Don’t use far too much detail, as most PhDs have done. Many details don’t help the reader. Two examples should be enough. Just give the bigger picture / idea.
-         Make it interesting. Show it to your supervisor.
-         Publishers are worried about length. Every four pages cost more money. Books are better for being shorter.
-         Even knowing rules it takes experience to work it out. Some publishers really don’t like PhD works.
-         Don’t mention the work PhD to a publisher. They will find out eventually but don’t mention it. The symbolic message here is that you know that what you want to publish is an interesting work.
-         Send a proposal which should be neat:
(a) outline main line of book in two, three or four paragraphs;
(b) provide chapters summary in two, three of four pages;
(c) indicate length of book;
(d) include target readers [if it is interdisciplinary don’t use the word ‘interdisciplinary’;
(e) schedule for delivery of final manuscript. Be serious about revision and allow time for it. Two months? If you need to do further research, allow more time;
(f) write a cover letter and show you know about them and thought about that particular one publisher.
-         You are trying to show how good you are for an intelligent and more experienced reader.
-         Academics usually take three months to respond to reading your piece.
-         Contact one publisher at a time. Same orientation applied to journals.
-         Make a note of it when you have had bits of your writing published elsewhere.
-         You can have an agent, but they are only interested if it is viable financially.
-         From 500 sold copies they give you 5%.
-         Write a very good academic book which gives you a name and voice in the field. This makes everything easier later on.
-         In some academic cultures the researcher / PhD student subsidises the publication, but it is the last resource. If you want an academic career you need a serious publisher.
-         Books: there are three categories:
(a)    Trade publishing: very commercial, they are interested in volume, in selling 10,000 copies. Ex: the flat tables Waterstones [a bookshop] books, with a nice cover; from publishers like Penguin.
(b)   College publishing: textbooks; school books for degree programmes
(c)    Academic publishing [the one we are interested in]: it sells from 500 to 2,000 copies. There are two major groups of publishers:
                                              I.            The university presses: Oxford UP, CUP, Harvard, Chicago, Indiana.
                                           II.            Commercial presses [less choosy]: McMillan, Palgrave, Longman Pearson.
                 If you think you have something good try CUP, OUP. If you get and the book is well
                 received you never have a problem publishing again.
-------








nota: esse post esta hoje tambem no meu blog no portalaz.

Monday, 10 May 2010

training session: writing

10 may 2010

Humanities training session
“Writing for a PhD: skills and techniques”
Monday 10th May
1 - 3 p.m. 65/1097
Instructor: Professor John McGavin

The session had 20 students. Very many people need support on their writing.
Precious tips from the beginning of the session: 1. stop thinking about yourself; 2. stop thinking about your reader. These should get you going.

We had two major group activities:

1. first part:
we were paired up with a student who is not from our same department, and swapped pieces of writing. First, we talked about our own subject area; then, we read each other’s papers.
My pair was Cristina, from Sweden. She is a first year PhD student in Archaeology, doing research on food culture from the Bronze age in Scandinavia.
My writing is not even a proper writing yet. It is only part of my thoughts on my methodology. I was hoping she would help me – give me ideas – on how to organise the writing.

Cristina's feedback on my writing: = I need to signpost my information and organise information.

I was at first frustrated with this feedback, because I hoped she would give me more, save me; suggest a structure to my mess. How could she say what I already knew? But, because she did not do so, I felt I was back in square zero. I kept thinking about her feedback and my expectations until I thought: ‘well, maybe my piece is not too bad after all. Maybe I only need to really revise it, and so what she suggests.’

What I learned from it: (a) writing is difficult, as repeated and cliché as it seems; yes, it is difficult. (b) we need other people’s eyes on our papers to point out what we can no longer see. An outside reader always proposes an alternative to our ideas. (c) I don’t know what should come first, if a draft (stream of consciousness writing) or an outline (a plan), because to organize a piece of writing from a draft is complicated and time-consuming.

From each one:
(a) reader’s need determines the info we provide
(b) linking, no hopping (between ideas / points)
(c) don’t assume too much knowledge on the reader – define terms
(d) long sentences are not preferable
(e) take care of jargon (it’s a potential danger to yourself. Jargons come in a package)
(f) simplicity is not bad
(g) reader has to understand sequence
(h) use a ragbag (good quotes in a separate file)
(i) don’t be afraid to empower the reader
(j) a problem in writing talks about a problem in thinking
(k) have a mixture between long and short sentences. Short sentences are better. Too long sentences read like writer is lost, not organized. Too short sentences mean no connection
(l) have a clear line of argument / goal, so that theory can support it
(m) keep aims up front and people can see them. Focus on argument
(n) stay aware of structure / function
(o) how to get started – revise – select – refine (???) what works best varies from person to person. Maybe you have to reorganize everything back again
(p) signpost coherent sequence.

2. second part
We formed different dyads to again exchange our pieces of writing. Peer chose (a) best sentence and (b) worst sentence. we talked about it, why I /she found this and that the worst / the best. My pair this time was Emilie, another Swedish girl, also from Archaeology. Her writing was too technical. I couldn’t understand much.

→ avoid:
- abstract words (value, concepts rather words related to the topic)
- too long footnotes. Put it in to the text
- words like: via, important
- inconfidence (get rid of that person and write to serve your reader. The ghost will disappear)

It was a very helpful training session. Maybe we should have it more often, same format / idea.